SAT in its order said, “We grant liberty to the appellant to mention the matter after pleadings are complete and consider the prayer at that time. Till the next date of hearing, the Para 537.3, effect of Para 537.3 shall diminish.
During the hearing, from Sathe's Senior Advocate Venkatesh Dhond, argued that the publication could create an impression that he was accepting wrongdoing even as he was contesting SEBI's findings. He said the academy was primarily engaged in educating students about the securities market and had trained around 63,000 people. According to him, SEBI had received 13-15 complaints, of which two were withdrawn.
Vekatesh Dhond from Sathe side said, “My bank accounts have been frozen. I have been prevented from, carrying on business, in the, not even business or for somebody else, prevented from dealing with securities. Then I am told, now deposit Rs 600 crores which is the disgorgement”.
SEBI side opposed the plea, Senior Advocate, Chetan Kapadia, argued that the collection of information from students who may be eligible for refunds should not be delayed until the appeal is finally decided. Its counsel said delaying the process could affect the identification of eligible claimants, particularly if the litigation continued for several years.
Chetan Kapadia from SEBI side said, “The collation of information means the persons who got lured by the investment advisory and research analysis activity which was carried out in his institute, in the name of education and who are accordingly entitled to refund. That information collation will not happen for the next six years”.